Cash home buyers serving Tulsa and all of Green Country, Oklahoma Fair cash offer in 24 hours · 918-200-9185

Should You Sell the Rental or Keep It?

What the property really returns after every cost, and what that return is on the equity sitting inside it.

Most small landlords judge a rental on the rent cheque. The number that actually matters is what it returns after everything, and what that return represents on the equity sitting inside the property doing nothing.

Put your real figures in. The calculation runs in your browser and nothing is sent anywhere unless you choose to send it at the end.

The property

Monthly unless the label says otherwise.

$
%
%
$
$
$
$
$
$

If you sold

$
$
%

What it actually returns

Gross rent, annual$0
Vacancy$0
Management$0
Tax and insurance$0
Maintenance and turns$0
Capital set-aside$0
Mortgage$0
Cash flow, annual$0
Per month$0
Equity tied up$0
Return on that equity0%
Net if you sold$0

The three numbers landlords get wrong

LineWhat usually happens
Capital set-asideLeft at zero, because the roof has not failed yet. On older Tulsa stock the roof, HVAC, water heater and supply plumbing all arrive within a few years of each other, and that bill is real whether or not it is budgeted
Your own managementEntered as zero because you do it yourself. That is a genuine cost in hours, and it is the thing most landlords actually want to stop doing
Turn costsUnderestimated, because the last turn was years ago. Materials and labour have risen faster than rents on older stock

What this tool will not tell you

It will not tell you what to do with the money if you sell. That is investment advice and we are property buyers, not advisers. It also leaves out appreciation, depreciation recapture and capital gains, all of which are real and all of which depend on facts specific to you. Our guide to capital gains on an Oklahoma sale is a starting point and a CPA is the finishing one.

On tax. We are not accountants and this is not tax advice. Basis, exclusions and what is owed depend on facts specific to you, and the rules change. Speak to a CPA or tax adviser before making a decision that turns on the tax position.

What it does show is the honest annual return on the equity currently sitting in the property. That number is worth knowing either way, including if the answer is that the rental is performing well and you should keep it.

Where each number comes from

This decision gets made on estimates far too often. Every field here has an actual record behind it, and the records usually tell a less flattering story than the estimates.

  • Rent. What is being paid, from your bank statements, not what the lease says and not what the unit would get if it were empty and refreshed today
  • Vacancy. Your own last three years. How many months was it empty between tenants, including the time spent turning it over
  • Mortgage. Your statement. Principal and interest, with tax and insurance separate or included but not both
  • Property tax and insurance. From the statements. And if the property is tenanted, confirm you are on the right kind of policy, because the wrong one is a claim waiting to be declined
  • Repairs and maintenance. Twelve months of actual spend from your bank, not a percentage. Most landlords underestimate this by half
  • Management. What you pay, or what you would pay if you stopped doing it yourself. If the plan involves moving away, this field is not optional
  • Utilities you cover, plus lawn, pest and anything else recurring
  • Value. From an agent's analysis or a written offer, not an online estimate

If you file a Schedule E, last year's is the fastest way to fill most of this in honestly.

The costs that only appear every few years

This is where keep-or-sell decisions go wrong. A property that looks fine on a monthly basis stops looking fine once the lumpy items are spread across the years they actually arrive in.

Take each of these, estimate what it costs and how often it happens, and add a monthly share of it to your expenses:

  • Turnover. Cleaning, paint, carpet, locks, listing and the empty weeks. The single most expensive recurring event in small residential rental
  • The roof, which has a life and is on a clock whether you think about it or not
  • HVAC and the water heater, same point, shorter lives
  • Flooring, every few tenancies
  • Sewer and plumbing, which on older Tulsa houses is not a hypothetical
  • An eviction, which costs filing, time, lost rent and usually a turnover on top. Our article on what an eviction costs in Oklahoma puts the components together
  • A bad year, meaning a tenant who stops paying and a quarter with no income
  • Storm damage and the deductible, which in this part of the country is a when rather than an if. Our article on the wind and hail deductible covers the part that is always yours

A property that only works when nothing breaks is a property that does not work.

The questions the arithmetic cannot answer

If the numbers are clear, follow them. They usually are not, and then the decision rests on things no calculator holds.

  • How far away will you be? Managing a rental from another state is a different job from managing one across town, and it is the job most accidental landlords discover they do not want
  • Who answers the telephone at eleven at night, and are you willing for it to be you
  • What is your tolerance for the bad version? A tenant who stops paying, a court date, a house that comes back needing work
  • Do you have reserves? Not notionally. Actually, in an account, for the roof and three empty months at the same time
  • What is the exit plan? If the intention is to sell in five years anyway, selling with a tenant in place narrows the buyer pool, and the condition after five more tenancies is not the condition today. Our page on selling a rental property in Tulsa covers that
  • Is this an investment or an inheritance you have not decided about? Keeping a house because selling it feels like a decision is itself a decision, and it is the expensive one. Our page on selling an inherited house covers the version of this that starts with an estate
  • And the tax position, which is a question for your own accountant and not for us. Our page on capital gains tax when selling an Oklahoma house covers the ground to raise with them

If the rent genuinely covers everything with room to spare, you have reserves and you want to own Tulsa property long term, keep it. We will say so on the call.

Want us to sanity check the hold?

Keeping a rental is frequently the right answer and this tool will say so. Send your figures and we will tell you which of the assumptions looks optimistic, whichever way the number came out.

Your figures are attached so the conversation starts from your numbers rather than from question one. We are not going to tell you to sell to us if the calculator has just shown you that listing nets more.

Questions about this

What should I use for repairs and maintenance?

Twelve months of actual spend from your bank statements rather than a percentage of rent. Most landlords underestimate this by about half, and last year's Schedule E is the fastest honest source for it.

What does this tool leave out?

The lumpy costs that only arrive every few years: turnover between tenants, the roof, HVAC and water heater, flooring, sewer work, an eviction, a quarter with no rent, and the storm deductible. Spread a monthly share of each across your expenses before deciding.

Should I include management if I manage it myself?

Include it if there is any chance you will stop, and definitely include it if the plan involves moving away. A rental managed from another state is a different proposition from one managed across town.

The numbers are close. How do I decide?

On the things the arithmetic does not hold: how far away you will be, who answers the telephone at eleven at night, whether you have real reserves for the roof and three empty months at once, and what the exit plan is. A property that only works when nothing breaks does not work.

How do I work out whether a rental is still worth keeping?

Take the rent, subtract vacancy, management, tax, insurance, maintenance, turn costs, a set-aside for big-ticket items and the mortgage. What is left is the cash flow. Divide it by the equity sitting in the property and you have the return that capital is actually earning.

What is a capital set-aside and why does it matter?

An annual amount put aside for the roof, HVAC, water heater and plumbing. Landlords routinely leave it at zero because nothing has failed yet, but on older Tulsa stock those items tend to arrive within a few years of each other and the bill is real whether or not it was budgeted.

I manage it myself, so should management be zero?

In cash terms yes, but it is not free. It is hours, and it is usually the part landlords most want to stop. Enter a percentage if you want to see what the property returns without you working on it.

Does this account for appreciation or tax?

No. It leaves out appreciation, depreciation recapture and capital gains, all of which are real and all of which depend on facts specific to you. A CPA is the right person for that side.

Can I sell a rental with tenants in it?

Yes. We buy with the lease in place and take over as landlord at closing, so nobody has to be moved out and you are not running an eviction to make a sale possible.

Will you buy more than one at a time?

Yes. If you hold two, three or five we will price them together as a single transaction rather than making you sell one at a time and carry the rest while you do.

Want that figure checked against the actual house?

A calculator works from what you type in. An offer works from the property itself, the condition and what comparable houses nearby have actually sold for.

  • A written offer within 24 hours, not a range on the phone
  • No repairs, no cleaning, no fees, and no showings
  • If listing would net you more, we say so
Prefer to talk it through first? 918-200-9185

No fees, no obligation, and your property is never listed publicly.